Real Friends

Shannon Hale wrote the graphic novel as a memoir of her elementary years.  (I adored her Books of Bayern series, beginning with The Goose Girl.)  As a middle-school read, I think it would be perfect... reflecting on the sometimes tortuous world of friendships and fitting in.  But as an elementary student, I think it would be scary.  She portrays such meanness in both the group she calls friends but mostly her sister, who not only verbally abuses her, but physically as well.  I almost didn't finish the book, but I was curious to discover its message.  I was relieved to discover that Shannon stood up for herself and left the group, and in doing so, became confident, a better friend and subsequently more attractive to be around.  I did appreciate the page in which she kicked the boys' butts who forced themselves on her and her friend.  She shared a very important message about you being in charge of your body.  But again - I will hold off buying this for my elementary libraries.  (GN HAL)